From the recent medical literature...
1. EMS, Emergency Depts Slowly Warm Up to Therapeutic Hypothermia
December 22, 2008 — One of the hottest topics in emergency medicine is a decidedly cold one: therapeutic hypothermia to prevent brain damage in patients after cardiac arrest.
New York City has announced that as of January 1, 2009, emergency medical services (EMS) will take patients who have been resuscitated after cardiac arrest to an emergency department (ED) trained and equipped to perform therapeutic hypothermia, rather than to a closer hospital that does not offer the treatment. Several other US cities, including Boston, Seattle, and Miami, have similar policies in place.
Research Supports NYC Move
In 2002, European and Australian investigators published results of separate studies in which patients who were successfully resuscitated after cardiac arrest caused by ventricular fibrillation were randomly assigned to undergo therapeutic hypothermia to a target temperature of 32° to 34° C or to standard treatment at normal temperatures.
In the European study, 55% of 75 patients treated with mild hypothermia for whom data were available had favorable neurologic outcomes compared with 39% of 137 patients treated according to standard protocols. Six-month overall mortality rates were also lower among patients treated with hyperthermia vs standard care, at 41% vs 55%, respectively. Complication rates were similar between the 2 groups, however (N Engl J Med. 2002;346:549-556).
Similarly, the Australian investigators found that 49% of 43 patients treated with hypothermia after out-of-hospital arrest survived and had a good outcome (discharge home or to rehabilitation) compared with 26% of 34 treated with normothermia. An analysis adjusted for baseline differences in age and time from collapse to the return of spontaneous circulation showed a more than 5-fold greater likelihood for a favorable outcome with hypothermia (N Engl J Med. 2002;346:557-563).
A retrospective study published in 2007 in the journal Resuscitation reported that among 40 consecutive comatose post–cardiac arrest patients with ST-elevation myocardial infarction who received early coronary angiography/percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI) and mild therapeutic hypothermia, the in-hospital mortality rate was 25% compared with 66% for matched historical controls who underwent PCI without therapeutic hypothermia. In all, 78% of patients (21 of 27) treated with hypothermia who survived out to 6 months had a good neurologic outcome compared with only half of control patients (6 of 12 survivors).
Slow Implementation of Hypothermia Programs
Stephan Mayer, MD, chief of the neurological intensive care unit at New York–Presbyterian/Columbia Hospital in New York City and a prominent advocate for NYC's adoption of the new protocol, asks why, if the evidence strongly supports the benefits of hypothermia, aren't more hospitals using it? "What we have is this problem of implementation," Dr. Mayer told Medscape Medical News. "We've known this for 6 years, since the clinical trials, and in addition there have been multiple single-center studies showing bad results with standard care, and when they implemented hypothermia, and have doubled the rate of survival."
Dr. Mayer said that because patients who are comatose after resuscitation have historically had a poor prognosis, there is an assumption by many clinicians that such patients will not benefit from aggressive interventions.
Bret A. Nicks, MD, assistant medical director in the Department of Emergency Medicine at Wake Forest University Baptist Medical Center in Winston-Salem, North Carolina, agrees that the technique has been accepted more slowly than many would like. "Considering that we're 6 years down the road from the clinical trials, most places have not adopted it, because of, number one, the perceived difficulties in starting it, and two, the perceived difficulties in continuing it in the intensive care unit setting," he told Medscape Medical News.
Better Coordination Needed
Dr. Nicks noted that although his center has had a protocol for therapeutic hypothermia in place for several years, "our biggest struggle is that [although] we can continue [ED-initiated hypothermia] in our cardiac intensive care unit, but not all postarrest patients go there; they may go to the medical intensive care unit depending on the nature of their illness, and maintaining that protocol and that concept to keep them cool for neuroprotective properties aren't as well established."
Better coordination of the protocol between the ED and other centers in his institution is a major goal for 2009, he said.
In several large urban centers, including Seattle, Wake County, North Carolina, and Richmond, Virginia, paramedics are trained and equipped for inducing hypothermia in the field. In Richmond, for example, paramedics can initiate cooling during resuscitation, and if the patient has return of spontaneous circulation, the cooling can be continued in transport, with rapid cooling initiated in the ED using a percutaneous catheter technique. The ambulances bypass other hospitals and take all suitable patients directly to Virginia Commonwealth University Medical Center for treatment.
In Wake County, the EMS system in 2006 began prehospital induction of hypothermia for patients with return of spontaneous circulation after cardiac arrest. In the program, all patients aged 16 years and older who are not neurologically intact after resuscitation from nontraumatic arrest are considered for induced cooling in the field, regardless of presenting rhythm. Here too, ambulances transport therapeutic hypothermia candidates directly to 1 of 2 hospitals where cooling can be induced 24 hours a day in the cardiac catheterization lab.
Cardiovascular Benefits of Hypothermia Less Clear
But while the neuroprotective benefits of therapeutic hypothermia are evident, the cardiovascular benefits are not quite as clear, according to Elliott Antman, MD, director of the Samuel A. Levine Cardiac Unit at Brigham & Women's Hospital in Boston, Massachusetts. "That hasn't been as well studied," he told Medscape Medical News. "There are theoretical benefits, but they have not been found to be as compelling as the neurologic benefits. The most important thing from a cardiovascular perspective is the door-to-balloon time."
In a consensus statement published in an advance online edition of Circulation by the International Liaison Committee on Resuscitation (ILCOR), the committee members state that the neuroprotective benefits of hypothermia are well established and that "[t]herapeutic hypothermia should be part of a standardized treatment strategy for comatose survivors of cardiac arrest."
Dr. Nicks said that instituting a therapeutic hypothermia protocol need not be overwhelming — it can be done with cooling blankets and a bear hugger air-cooling device to make a "patient sandwich," plus cool fluids to reach the goal temperatures for mild hypothermia.
"You don't have to go out and buy the expensive central line cooling kit," he said.
But Dr. Mayer noted that low-tech cooling methods are labor intensive, and the methods are less precise than dedicated cooling systems.
"The hours go by and you're not getting the temperatures down where you want them to be, or you're getting them too cold and if the body temperature goes below thirty, you can actually cause ventricular arrhythmia," he pointed out. "The newer technologies work, they're powerful, and the target temperature can be achieved in an hour or two."
Dr. Mayer reports that he is a consultant to Medivance, maker of therapeutic hypothermia equipment, and holds stock in the company. None of the other physicians interviewed have disclosed any relevant financial relationships.
2. Coordination by Hospitalists Eases Emergency Department Crowding
By David Douglas. NEW YORK (Reuters Health) Dec 09 - Active bed management by hospitalists can reduce emergency department (ED) congestion and increase throughput, Maryland-based researchers report in the December 2nd issue of the Annals of Internal Medicine.
"Our study," lead investigator Dr. Eric Howell told Reuters Health, "showed that hospitalists can be part of an effective solution for ED crowding, as well as help solve inpatient hospital capacity issues -- including ICU capacity."
Dr. Howell of Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, and colleagues explain that the intervention included real-time monitoring of bed availability in ICUs, intermediate care and other units, as well as regular visits to the ED to assess congestion and flow of patients, and to facilitate transfers to appropriate units.
The researchers then compared data from the intervention period (from November 2006 to February 2007) with that from November 2005 to February 2006, prior to the intervention.
During the intervention period there was an 8.8% increase in patients (17,573 versus 16,148). However, throughput for patients who were admitted fell by 98 minutes (360 versus 458 minutes). There was no change in throughput for patients who were not admitted.
The amount of time that ambulances had to be diverted because of ED crowding fell by 6%, and there was a 27% drop in diversion time because of lack of ICU beds.
Dr. Howell concluded that "it is interesting that our study shows that hospitalists can have a dramatic impact on improving quality and efficiency in areas outside of the medical floor -- where hospitalists traditionally care for patients -- like the ED or ICU."
Ann Intern Med 2008;149:804-810. Abstract: http://www.annals.org/cgi/content/abstract/149/11/804
3. Festive Medical Myths
Vreeman RC, Carroll AE. BMJ 2008;337:a2769 [References not included.]
In the pursuit of scientific truth, even widely held medical beliefs require examination or re-examination. Both physicians and non-physicians sometimes believe things about our bodies that just are not true. As a reminder of the need to apply scientific investigation to conventional wisdom, we previously discussed the evidence disputing seven commonly held medical myths.1 The holiday season presents a further opportunity to probe medical beliefs recounted during this time of the year.
We generated a list of common medical or health beliefs related to the holidays and winter season and searched Medline for scientific evidence to support or refute these beliefs. If we couldn’t find any evidence in the medical literature, we searched the internet using Google.
Sugar causes hyperactivity in children
While sugarplums may dance in children’s heads, visions of holiday sweets terrorise parents with anticipation of hyperactive behaviour. Regardless of what parents might believe, however, sugar is not to blame for out of control little ones. At least 12 double blind randomised controlled trials have examined how children react to diets containing different levels of sugar.2 None of these studies, not even studies looking specifically at children with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder, could detect any differences in behaviour between the children who had sugar and those who did not.3 This includes sugar from sweets, chocolate, and natural sources. Even in studies of those who were considered "sensitive" to sugar, children did not behave differently after eating sugar full or sugar-free diets.3
Scientists have even studied how parents react to the sugar myth. When parents think their children have been given a drink containing sugar (even if it is really sugar-free), they rate their children’s behaviour as more hyperactive.4 The differences in the children’s behaviour were all in the parents’ minds.4
Suicides increase over the holidays
Holidays can bring out the worst in us. The combined stresses of family dysfunction, exacerbations in loneliness, and more depression over the cold dark winter months are commonly thought to increase the number of suicides. While the holidays might, indeed, be a difficult time for some, there is no good scientific evidence to suggest a holiday peak in suicides.5 6 7
One study from Japan that looked at suicides in 1979-94 showed that the rate of suicide was lowest in the days before a holiday and highest in the days after the holiday.8 In contrast, in a study from the United States of suicides over a 35 year period, there was no increase before, during, or after holidays.9 Indeed, people might actually experience increased emotional and social support during holidays. In the US, rates of psychiatric visits decrease before Christmas and increase again afterwards.10 A smaller study of adolescents showed a peak in suicide attempts at the end of the school year,11 possibly reflecting a decrease in social support. Data from Ireland on suicide in 1990-8 also failed to connect suicides with the holidays.12 While Irish women were no more likely to commit suicide on holidays than on any other days, Irish men were actually significantly less likely to do so.
Further debunking myths about suicide, people are not more likely to commit suicide during the dark winter months. Around the world, suicides peak in warmer months and are actually lowest in the winter. In Finland, suicides peak in autumn and are lowest in the winter.13 In a 30 year study of suicides in Hungary, researchers again found the highest rates of suicides in the summer and the lowest in the winter.14 Studies of suicide rates from India also show peaks in April and May.15 Studies from the US reflect this pattern, with lower rates in November and December than in typically warmer months.6
Of course, none of this evidence suggests that suicides do not happen over the holidays. The epidemiological evidence just does not support that the holidays are a time of increased risk.
With flowers and leaves of red, green, and white, poinsettias are widely used in holiday decorations. Even though public health officials have reported that poinsettias are safe, many continue to believe this is a poisonous plant.16
In an analysis of 849 575 plant exposures reported to the American Association of Poison Control Centers,17 none of the 22 793 cases involving poinsettia resulted in considerable poisoning.17 No one died from exposure to or ingestion of poinsettia, and most (96%) did not even require medical treatment. In 92 of the cases, children ingested substantial quantities of poinsettias, but none needed medical treatment, and toxicologists concluded that poinsettia exposures and ingestions can be treated without referral to a healthcare facility.17 Another study, looking at poinsettia ingestion by rats, could not find a toxic amount of poinsettia, even at amounts that would be the equivalent of 500-600 poinsettia leaves or nearly a kilogram of sap.18
Excess heat loss in the hatless
As temperatures drop, hats and caps flourish. Even the US Army Field manual for survival recommends covering your head in cold weather because "40 to 45 percent of body heat" is lost through the head.19 If this were true, humans would be just as cold if they went without trousers as if they went without a hat. But patently this is just not the case.
This myth probably originated with an old military study in which scientists put subjects in arctic survival suits (but no hats) and measured their heat loss in extremely cold temperatures.20 Because it was the only part of the subjects’ bodies that was exposed to the cold, they lost the most heat through their heads. Experts say, however, that had this experiment been performed with subjects wearing only swimsuits, they would not have lost more than 10% of their body heat through their heads.20 A more recent study confirms that there is nothing special about the head and heat loss.21 Any uncovered part of the body loses heat and will reduce the core body temperature proportionally. So, if it is cold outside, you should protect your body. But whether you want to keep your head covered or not is up to you.
Nocturnal feasting makes you fat
Holiday feasts and festivities present us with many culinary options. A common suggestion to avoid unwanted weight gain is to avoid eating at night, and at first glance, some scientific studies seem to support this. In a study of 83 obese and 94 non-obese women in Sweden, the obese women reported eating more meals, and their meals were shifted to the afternoon, evening, or night.22 But just because obesity and eating more meals at night are associated, it does not mean that one causes the other. People gain weight because they take in more calories overall than they burn up. The obese women were not just night eaters, they were also eating more meals, and taking in more calories makes you gain weight regardless of when calories are consumed.
Other studies found no link at all between eating at night and weight gain. Swedish men did not show any evidence of gaining weight with night time meals.23 In a study of 86 obese and 61 normal weight men, there were no differences in the timing of when they ate.23 Another study of 15 obese people found that the timing of meals did not change the circadian rhythm pattern of energy expenditure.24 In a study of over 2500 patients, eating at night was not associated with weight gain, but eating more than three times a day was linked to being overweight or obese.25 Studies have connected skipping breakfast with gaining more weight, but this is not because breakfast skippers eat more at night.26 Breakfast skippers eat more during the rest of the day. Records of calorie intake suggest that those who eat breakfast maintain healthy weights because their calorie intake is more evenly distributed over the day.26 27 In other words, when you eat three regular meals, you are not as likely to overeat at any one particular meal or time.
You can cure a hangover
From aspirin and bananas to Vegemite and water, internet searches present seemingly endless options for preventing or treating alcohol hangovers.28 Even medical experts offer suggestions.29
No scientific evidence, however, supports any cure or effective prevention for alcohol hangovers. A systematic review of randomised trials evaluating medical interventions for preventing or treating hangovers found no effective interventions in either traditional or complementary medicine.28 While a few small studies using unvalidated symptom scores showed minor improvements, the conclusion of the exhaustive review was that propranolol, tropisetron, tolfenamic acid, fructose or glucose, and dietary supplements including borage, artichoke, prickly pear, and Vegemite all failed to effectively "cure hangovers." While more recent studies in rats show some potential for new products to alter mechanisms associated with hangovers,30 31 humans also face risks when using certain "hangover cures."32 A hangover is caused by excess alcohol consumption. Thus, the most effective way to avoid a hangover is to consume alcohol only in moderation or not at all.
Examining common medical myths reminds us to be aware of when evidence supports our advice, and when we operate based on unexamined beliefs. This was not a systematic review of either the evidence to refute these medical myths or of doctors’ beliefs. None the less, we applied rigorous search methods to compile data, and evidence of the prevalence of these medical beliefs is readily available. Only by investigation, discussion, and debate can we reveal the existence of such myths and move the field of medicine forward.
4. Women with STEMI Fare Worse Than Men
Lisa Nainggolan. From Heartwire — a professional news service of WebMD. December 10, 2008 — A contemporary look at whether there are still differences between men and women in terms of medical care and outcomes after acute myocardial infarction (AMI) has revealed that the situation appears to be improving for women but that there is still some way to go to achieve equality .
In their report published online December 8, 2008 in Circulation, Dr Hani Jneid (Baylor College of Medicine and Michael E De Bakey VA Medical Center, Houston, TX) and colleagues analyzed data from the American Heart Association (AHA) Get With the Guidelines program and found no differences between the sexes in terms of in-hospital mortality from AMI. However, women with ST-elevation MI (STEMI) were still more likely than men to die in the hospital.
Our work is still cut out for us
"It's disturbing that there is still a persistent gap in mortality in the highest-risk STEMI group," Jneid told heartwire. "We were able to close the gap between the sexes after adjusting for age and risk factors, but we found a disparity across the board in all treatments between women and men and a disturbing delay in treatment in women compared with men. We have room to improve on the healthcare and outcome of women when they present with this severe type of heart attack."
Dr Nieca Goldberg (Women's Heart Center, New York University, NY), an AHA spokesperson who was not involved in the research but has a special interest in women's health, told heartwire: "I'm disappointed by this research, as there have been a lot of campaigns to increase awareness about cardiovascular disease in women. It seems like we've improved our care in women with non-STEMI, but it's kind of confusing to me why women with a STEMI come in and are more likely to die." She adds that she is reassured that doctors seem to have gotten better at treating the subtler forms of heart attack, "but our work is still cut out for us."
Women less likely to receive adequate therapies
In their study, Jneid et al examined sex differences in care processes and in-hospital deaths among 78,254 patients with AMI in 420 US hospitals from 2001 to 2006. Women, in general, were older, had more comorbidities, less often presented with STEMI, and had higher unadjusted in-hospital death (8.2% vs 5.7% for men; p less than 0.0001).
But after multivariate adjustment, sex differences in in-hospital mortality were no longer apparent in the overall AMI cohort (adjusted odds ratio 1.04), although they persisted among STEMI patients (mortality rate 10.2% among women compared with 5.5% in men; p less than 0.0001; adjusted odds ratio [OR] 1.12).
This excess death seen in women with STEMI was primarily accounted for by an excess of very early deaths among women in the initial 24 hours of hospitalization, the researchers note. Women were less likely to receive early medical treatments, acute reperfusion therapies, timely pharmacological and mechanical reperfusion, and invasive procedures.
"This tells us that there are true disparities," Jneid says.
5. No Benefit of TNK in Cardiac Arrest: TROICA Published
from Heartwire — a professional news service of WebMD. December 19, 2008 — The first large-scale trial to investigate the addition of the thrombolytic tenecteplase (TNK) to standard cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) — which showed no increase in survival in cardiac-arrest patients given such therapy — has been published in the December 19, 2008, issue of the New England Journal of Medicine. The results were first presented at the World Congress of Cardiology in Barcelona two years ago, as reported by heartwire.
Lead author Dr Bernd Boettiger (University of Cologne, Germany), who also presented the study — called Thrombolysis in Cardiac Arrest (TROICA) — in Barcelona, told heartwire that nothing has changed between the presentation and publication, except for the fact that the survival rates reported in Barcelona were slightly higher, because asystolic patients were excluded from the analysis. "The New England Journal of Medicine recommended that we include the asystolic patients (n = 209), so we have a slightly lower survival rate in the paper by incorporating these patients with a very poor prognosis," he remarked.
Nevertheless, the overall conclusion is the same, he says. "In the setting of witnessed cardiac arrest of presumed cardiac origin, there is no additional benefit from the use of TNK without concomitant antithrombotic treatment. This was a result that was very disappointing to us, as we did expect it would help very much."
But as he stressed in Barcelona, Boettiger is not yet ready to give up on this strategy completely. "Further investigation has to focus on combining TNK treatment with anticoagulants, such as heparin, and other things. We are working on further trials because we are convinced that anticoagulation plays a role in reperfusion after cardiac arrest, and we have been discussing with industry as to how we can proceed from here."
Boettiger BW, Arntz HR, Chamberlain DA, et al. Thrombolysis during resuscitation for out-of-hospital cardiac arrest. N Engl J Med. 2008;359:2651-2662. Abstract: http://content.nejm.org/cgi/content/abstract/359/25/2651
6. Inhaled corticosteroids don’t reduce mortality in stable COPD
Like most drug treatments for chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), inhaled corticosteroids are better at symptom control and preventing exacerbations than they are at saving lives. The latest meta-analysis to look specifically at mortality found that long term inhaled steroids made no difference to survival for people with stable disease but did increase the risk of pneumonia.
The authors found 11 randomised trials evaluating fluticasone, triamcinolone, and budesonide, alone or in combination with other inhaled drugs, usually salmeterol. The trials tested treatments that lasted at least six months and studied more than 14 000 adults between them. Relative risk of death was 0.86 (95% CI 0.68 to 1.09) in patients treated with inhaled steroids, compared with controls given placebo or other inhaled drugs. Subgroup analyses looking at the effect of duration of treatment, type of product (monotherapy or combined), severity of disease, and dose were all negative. Inhaled corticosteroids were associated with a significant 34% increase in the risk of pneumonia (1.34, 1.03 to 1.75), but no extra fractures (1.09, 0.89 to 1.33).
Because this treatment seems to have no effect on mortality, doctors must weigh up the other risks (pneumonia) and benefits (fewer exacerbations, improved quality of life) when making therapeutic decisions in patients with stable chronic pulmonary obstructive disease, say the authors. As usual, the balance will vary between different subgroups. In this analysis, risk of pneumonia was highest in patients with the poorest lung function, those given higher doses, and those treated with combined products. Doctors who decide to prescribe inhaled steroids should use the lowest effective dose, say the authors.
7. They Don’t Train ’em Like They Used to
Taylor JS, et al. BMJ 2008;337:a2895. [Tables not included.]
To check perceptions that the younger generation are lacking the etiquette of their seniors, we reviewed over 300 radiology request forms written on a single weekday in a hospital on the south coast of England. We used the presence of the word "please" on the request form as a proxy measure of courtesy (table 1).
Table 1. Use of "please" on radiology request forms
Consultants and associate specialists came out on top. Junior hospital doctors (all grades) did less well, although better than nurses. Overall, the staff in the intensive therapy unit and the accident and emergency department scored modestly.
Among consultants, those in general surgery and general medicine were the most courteous, and orthopaedic surgeons conformed to their alledged stereotype of never requesting politely. However, the results for orthopaedic juniors give faint grounds for hope.
Graduates of Birmingham, Bristol, and Nottingham medical schools seemed the most polite, although the numbers are small (table 2). Foundation year docotors’ results were variable, with notable politeness from St George’s Medical School. Senior trainees from Guy’s, King’s and St Thomas’ and from Cambridge also scored very well.
Table 2. Use of "please" on radiology request forms, by medical school
Our investigation shows that seniors still set the gold standard for chivalry, with the rest of us only hoping to emulate them.
8. The fattening truth about restaurant food
Karen McColl. BMJ 2008;337:a2229
Going out to eat is often a disaster for the waistline. Karen McColl reports on US efforts to make diners more aware of what they are eating
Customers going into restaurant chains like Burger King or Starbucks in New York can now take calories into account when they choose what to eat. Since May, chain restaurants in the city have been required to include calorie contents on menu boards, menus, and item tags. The law applies to restaurant chains with more than 15 branches nationally.
Similar menu labelling, or "calorie posting," laws came into force in September in San Francisco and Santa Clara County in California, and the requirement will soon apply to the whole state. Arnold Schwarzenegger has now approved an amended version of a menu labelling bill that he vetoed last year, making California the first state to pass a menu labelling law. Around 20 cities and states across the US are considering menu labelling legislation. But the restaurant industry is fighting all the way.
"It’s just the most astonishing thing I’ve ever seen," says Marion Nestle from New York University. Professor Nestle is an academic nutritionist with decades of experience advising on nutrition issues. Yet, since calories have been posted on menus in New York she has been surprised. "For someone like me who thinks that they know about these things, I’m stunned by the number of calories in fast foods. I had no idea." As examples, she cites a blueberry and pomegranate smoothie that provides 1180 kcal (4.9 MJ) and a pizza for one person with more than 2000 kcal (8.3 MJ).
Professor Nestle is not the only nutrition expert to have difficulty assessing the nutritional content of fast food. The Food Commission recently asked 66 nutrition experts at an international obesity conference whether they could tell from the menu description which food was likely to contain most energy or fat. None of the experts answered all five questions correctly, and only a quarter answered more than two questions correctly.
Given that nutrition experts have difficulty choosing the healthiest options, what hope for the rest of the population? Research shows that consumers, like nutrition experts, have difficulty assessing the calorie content of fast food items and that people tend to underestimate energy content.
It is because people find it difficult to estimate calories that these laws are being introduced as part of an effort to tackle obesity, which now affects a third of US adults. Another key factor is the importance of eating out in the overall diet. Americans consume around one third of their calories outside the home, and nearly three quarters of all restaurant visits are to fast food or other chain restaurants. A survey of over 7000 fast food customers by New York’s health department found that a third (34%) of respondents purchased 1000 kilocalories or more at lunchtime.6 Research also shows that when calorie information is given people tend to choose high calorie items less often.6 7 We also know that consumers—both in the US and the UK—strongly favour having more accessible nutrition information when they eat out.
"We’re confident that this law will have two positive effects," says Tom Frieden, New York’s health commissioner. "The first is to encourage restaurants to offer healthier options, and the second will be to encourage some customers to make healthier choices." Dr Frieden estimates that the legislation could result in 150 000 fewer New Yorkers being obese and 30 000 fewer cases of diabetes in the city over the next five years.
Although many fast food chains already make nutrition information available, few customers see this information. At the time of the New York survey only Subway provided information at the point of purchase. Among customers of other outlets, just 4% reported seeing calorie information. Some nutrition information is available on company websites. Calculations based on figures from McDonald’s, which now also provides nutrition information on the back of tray liners, show that its nutrition information website receives one hit for every 25 000 meals sold. Where restaurants provide nutrition information leaflets on site, public health advocates argue that this information is overly complex and is not readily accessible when consumers order their food.
The key concept behind the menu labelling rules is to provide information in places where people will see it when they are choosing what to order. That means on menu boards and menus. Fast food restaurants describe the menu board as their most important means of communicating with customers, and this is one of the reasons that they have been resisting the legislation so strongly.
Although it is still too early to evaluate the impact of the new law, newspaper and blogs have been full of reports quoting shocked customers. Dr Frieden says that preliminary feedback suggests consumers are becoming more aware of calories, and some outlets are also starting to change what is on offer. There are reports of leading chains highlighting lower calorie options on the menus and introducing healthier options.
"What you hear essentially is sticker shock about the number of [kilo]calories in some common items—whether it’s a 600 calorie cup of coffee, a 1200 calorie salad, a 1400 calorie breakfast, or a 2700 calorie appetiser," Dr Frieden says.
Professor Nestle agrees that some New Yorkers are in shock, but is concerned that the numbers mean little to people who do not know that a typical adult needs only around 2000 kilocalories a day. "It’s a good thing, but it needs to be accompanied by a very clear know your number message so that you know that you should be aiming to consume somewhere in the 2000 range every day," she said. The California legislation does require restaurants to include information explaining recommended intakes in nutrition leaflets. In October the New York Health Department launched an advertising campaign to get the message across that most adults need no more than 2000 kilocalories a day to maintain a healthy weight. Dr Frieden also points out that even if you don’t know how many calories you should be consuming in a day, you can still use the calorie information to compare items and make healthier choices.
The restaurant industry has been vigorously opposing the menu labelling legislation. The New York State Restaurant Association has challenged the legislation in court, arguing that the regulation overlaps with federal law and violates their members’ free speech by compelling them to deliver a government message about the importance of calories. The court rejected both arguments in April. The association has appealed, and the appeal court’s decision is expected any day now. In the meantime, restaurants have to comply with the legislation.
In Seattle (King County), industry lobbying and pressure from the state legislature obtained a compromise that allows calories to be posted on signs next to menu boards or on eye level signs at the point of ordering instead of menu boards.
As well as using the legal systems to get menu labelling revoked, the restaurant industry is lobbying for legislation to ban such laws being passed in the first place. Ohio and Georgia have recently passed state measures that prohibit any local authorities from introducing menu labelling legislation. There are signs that some restaurant chains now accept that these rules are here to stay. Yum brands, which owns the Pizza Hut and KFC chains, announced on 1 October that it will introduce calorie counts on menu boards in its 20 000 US outlets by 2011.
9. GASP! Agonal Breathing Common, Predicts Survival After Out-of-Hospital Cardiac Arrest
from Heartwire — a professional news service of WebMD. Steve Stiles. November 27, 2008 (Tucson, AZ) - Someone stricken with out-of-hospital cardiac arrest might still be gasping for air, but that's no reason for witnesses to avoid jumping in with chest compressions, according to researchers who studied the phenomenon . On the contrary, that initial period of distressed breathing might last only minutes but provides the best chance for resuscitation efforts to succeed and allow the patient to survive to hospital discharge, suggests a retrospective analysis published online November 24, 2008 in Circulation.
About a third of more than 1200 cases of witnessed out-of-hospital cardiac arrest attended by Arizona emergency medical services (EMS) over a recent three-year period were characterized by gasping, "often referred to as snoring, snorting, gurgling, or moaning, or as agonal, barely, labored, noisy, or heavy breathing," report the authors, led by Dr Bentley J Bobrow (Mayo Clinic College of Medicine, Phoenix, AZ, and University of Arizona Sarver Heart Center, Tucson). Gasping was most frequent in the early minutes after the patients collapsed.
The patients who gasped, compared with those who didn't, were overall three times more likely to survive to hospital discharge, but were five times more likely if they received bystander cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR).
Gasping is an indication that you're doing a great job and you shouldn’t stop.
The incidence and prognostic implications of gasping at cardiac arrest are underappreciated, a shortfall in public education that can delay or discourage bystander participation, according to Bobrow et al. "It is not uncommon to hear anecdotal reports that bystanders (even medical professionals) failed to initiate CPR because they concluded that the patient was still breathing and therefore did not have a cardiac arrest," they write. (Their study, however, does not show this.)
The gasping is a sign of poor but marginally adequate cerebral perfusion, and it is promising whether it starts as the patient collapses or only after the beginning of CPR, according to coauthor Dr Gordon A Ewy (University of Arizona Sarver Heart Center). Lay people who initiate CPR tend to be startled if gasping occurs, believing the patient is "waking up," and then often stop what they are doing, he said to heartwire. But, "gasping is an indication that you're doing a great job and you shouldn’t stop."
In a review of records from the Phoenix Fire Department Regional Dispatch Center, the authors observed that 44 of 113 cases (39%) of witnessed and unwitnessed out-of-hospital cardiac arrests were characterized by abnormal breathing.
They looked at the phenomenon's prevalence in relation to EMS response times for 1218 cases of witnessed out-of-hospital cardiac arrest occurring in Arizona from 2004 to 2007. Whether EMS personnel observed gasping was inversely related to how soon they arrived after the patient's collapse.
Gasping was associated with a significantly increased odds of survival to hospital discharge, the study's primary end point--whether or not, but especially if, bystander CPR was performed.
Gasping was observed by EMS personnel in 33% of cases when collapse occurred with EMS on the scene, and the rate steadily decreased with EMS arrival times: 20% for less than 7 minutes, 14% for 7 to 9 minutes, and 7.5% for more than 9 minutes. The odds ratio for gasping with EMS arrival beyond 9 minutes after collapse was 0.30, compared with less than 7 minutes (p less than 0.001) after adjustment for age, sex, whether bystander CPR was performed, location of cardiac arrest, and whether VF was documented.
Ewy is among the principal advocates of what he calls cardiocerebral resuscitation for arrest of cardiac origin, characterized most notably by an emphasis on chest compressions uninterrupted by assisted breathing. The technique, as previously reported by heartwire, was recently endorsed by the American Heart Association as being about as effective as the traditional method involving compressions plus "mouth to mouth" resuscitation.
But proponents of the chest-compression-only method say it is superior, not only in being more successful but in encouraging bystanders to attempt it in the first place. In fact, Ewy said, the current study was designed, in part, to help get the public and providers to see abnormal breathing as a reason to initiate or continue CPR rather than a reason to stop or avoid it.
Ewy has no industry-related disclosures; of his coauthors, Dr Robert A Berg (University of Arizona Sarver Heart Center) discloses grant support from Medtronic and Dr Karl B Kern (University of Arizona Sarver Heart Center) reports being on the scientific advisory committees of Zoll and PhysioControl.
10. Health, Emergency Staff Get Drugs First in Pandemic
WASHINGTON (Reuters) Dec 17 - Health care and emergency services workers who might help sick people during an influenza pandemic should take antiviral drugs throughout the epidemic, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services said in new guidance released on Tuesday.
Employers such as hospitals should be responsible for stockpiling the drugs and designating who gets them, HHS said in its latest guidance.
People with weakened immune systems, such as cancer patients, should also get so-called prophylactic antivirals, which means taking them before they ever get sick, HHS said.
Two antiviral drugs can both prevent and treat all forms of influenza A, including H5N1. They are Roche and Gilead Sciences Inc's Tamiflu and GlaxoSmithKline and Biota Holdings Ltd's Relenza.
"Planning and preparing for a pandemic influenza requires action by every part of society, including individuals and families, communities, and private sector employers as well as all levels of government," Dr. Craig Vanderwagen, HHS assistant secretary for preparedness and response, said in a statement.
"Employers will play a key role in protecting employees' health and safety, which in turn reduces the impact of a pandemic on the nation's health, the economy and society."
HHS earlier encouraged employers to stockpile the drugs, which can both treat and prevent flu.
In July, HHS said about a million essential health care workers would be immunized first if a flu pandemic broke out in the United States.
Many public health experts agree some sort of influenza pandemic is inevitable, although no one can predict when it might come and how severe it may be.
It is also impossible to predict what strain of flu might cause it, although H5N1 avian influenza is the main suspect now. It has become entrenched in birds in Asia, Europe, the Middle East and possibly Africa.
While just 390 people have been infected since 2003 and 246 have died, experts fear H5N1 could acquire the ability to spread easily from human to human, setting off a pandemic that could kill hundreds of millions of people.
11. Head and neck injury risks in heavy metal: head bangers stuck between rock and a hard bass
Patton D, et al. BMJ 2008;337:a2825
Objective: To investigate the risks of mild traumatic brain injury and neck injury associated with head banging, a popular dance form accompanying heavy metal music.
Design Observational studies, focus group, and biomechanical analysis.
Participants: Head bangers.
Main outcome measures: Head Injury Criterion and Neck Injury Criterion were derived for head banging styles and both popular heavy metal songs and easy listening music controls.
Results: An average head banging song has a tempo of about 146 beats per minute, which is predicted to cause mild head injury when the range of motion is greater than 75°. At higher tempos and greater ranges of motion there is a risk of neck injury.
Conclusion: To minimise the risk of head and neck injury, head bangers should decrease their range of head and neck motion, head bang to slower tempo songs by replacing heavy metal with adult oriented rock, only head bang to every second beat, or use personal protective equipment.
12. Safety Improvements Mandated for Emergency Dept Design, Management
Laurie Barclay, MD. December 9, 2008 — Safety improvements in emergency department (ED) design and management are needed, according to a survey of emergency department clinicians reported in the December 5 issue of the Annals of Emergency Medicine.
"This is a national problem," lead author David Magid, MD, senior scientist at the Kaiser Permanente Colorado Institute for Health Research and director for research at the Colorado Permanente Medical Group in Denver, said in a news release. "It doesn't matter if the hospital is big or small, an academic or community-based institution, or the region of the country."
The study objective was to evaluate the degree to which EDs are designed, managed, and supported in ways that promote patient safety.
"A basic tenet of quality and safety theory is that personnel involved in daily work are often best informed to identify problems that threaten quality and safety in the workplace," the study authors write. "According to previous work on the state of US EDs and the prevalence of safety problems in EDs, we hypothesized that reports of ED personnel would reveal multiple opportunities to improve ED systems in ways that might contribute to safety of care."
Clinicians working in 65 US EDs completed a validated, psychometrically tested survey evaluating their observations and opinions regarding the EDs' physical environment, staffing, equipment and supplies, nursing, teamwork, safety culture, triage and monitoring, and coordination of information flow, consultation, and flow to inpatient departments.
Response rate was 66%, with 3562 eligible respondents completing the survey. The participants often reported problems in 4 systems vital to ED safety: physical environment, staffing, inpatient coordination, and information coordination and consultation. Across all 9 domains surveyed, few respondents reported that support systems were adequate most or all of the time.
Space was reported to be inadequate for the delivery of care most (25%) or some (37%) of the time. In addition, clinicians reported that the number of patients exceeded ED capacity to ensure safe care most (32%) or some (50%) of the time.
Only 41% of respondents reported that most of the time, specialty consultation for critically ill patients arrived within 30 minutes of being contacted, and half reported that ED patients needing intensive care unit admission were rarely transferred from the ED to the intensive care unit within 1 hour.
About 40% of respondents reported that physician staffing is inadequate to handle patient loads during busy periods, two thirds reported that nursing staff is insufficient to handle patient loads during busy periods, and one third reported that patients in the ED's waiting rooms are monitored often.
"Reports by ED clinicians suggest that substantial improvements in institutional design, management, and support for emergency care are necessary to maximize patient safety in US EDs," the study authors write. "Our results suggest that conditions may be somewhat better in smaller, non–residency-affiliated EDs."
Study limitations include lack of generalizability to all US EDs, reliance on clinician report rather than direct observation of the conditions being investigated, and an inability to determine whether perceived deficiencies were actually associated with hazard or harm to patients.
Factors that may hinder provision of safe ED care may include loss of information during handoffs at change of shift and frequent interruptions of ED clinicians.
"Gaining access to a patient's medical record is often difficult, and the availability of computers in the ED is frequently inadequate," the study authors conclude. "Finally, with respect to safety culture, the blaming of individuals for safety problems remains common, and hospital administrators are frequently perceived not to be supportive of improving patient safety.
This study was supported by the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality.
Ann Emerg Med. Published online December 5, 2008. Abstract: http://www.annemergmed.com/article/S0196-0644(08)01863-5/abstract
13. In Upper GI Bleeding, Choosing Who Gets Admitted and Who Goes Home
A scoring system based on simple clinical evaluation and without the need for endoscopy can identify low-risk patients who present with upper gastrointestinal bleeding, according to a Lancet study released online.
Researchers compared two scoring systems for predicting level of risk in patients presenting with upper GI hemorrhage to four U.K. hospitals — the widely used Rockall score and the newer Glasgow-Blatchford bleeding score (GBS). (The GBS is based on lab values — namely, blood urea and hemoglobin — along with systolic pressure, pulse, and presenting signs. Patients with normal values and no melena, syncope, or evidence of liver disease or heart failure are considered to be at low risk and thus eligible for outpatient management.)
The GBS outperformed the Rockall score at identifying low-risk patients in the emergency room, resulting in fewer hospitalizations. None of the patients with low-risk GBS required intervention for hemorrhage or had died after at least 6 months' follow-up.
The Lancet. Published online December 15, 2008.
14. Epidemic of Overdose Deaths Linked to Nonmedical Use of Prescription Opioids
December 11, 2008 — Up to 93% of unintentional overdose deaths in West Virginia, 1 of the poorest US states, are due to nonmedical use of prescription pharmaceuticals, primarily opioid analgesics, new research shows.
A population-based, observational study by investigators at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), in Atlanta, Georgia, shows nearly two-thirds of all drug-overdose deaths involved prescription diversion, meaning those who died did not have prescriptions for the drugs that killed them.
"We had anticipated that drug diversion would be an important contributor to these [overdose] deaths. However, the finding that nearly two-thirds of the deaths involved prescription drug diversion was particularly noteworthy," principal investigator Aron J. Hall, DVM, told Medscape Psychiatry.
Furthermore, investigators found that "doctor shopping" was a major contributor to unintentional drug-overdose mortality. "Roughly 1 in 5 of those who died had evidence of doctor shopping, which was defined as an individual who had 5 or more health providers in the previous year writing prescriptions for controlled substances," he said.
Hall AJ, et al. JAMA. 2008;300:2613-2620. Abstract: http://jama.ama-assn.org/cgi/content/abstract/300/22/2613
15. Internet-Based CME Leads to Good Evidence-Based Clinical Choices
NEW YORK (Reuters Health) Dec 10 - Physicians who participate in selected internet-based continuing medical education (CME) activities are more likely to make evidence-based clinical decisions than their counterparts who do not participate in these types of CME, according to new research.
Linda Casebeer of Outcomes, Inc., in Birmingham, Alabama, and colleagues with Medscape, LLC, of New York, Harvard Medical School in Boston, and the University of Alabama at Birmingham, conducted a controlled trial of the effectiveness of 48 internet-based CME activities.
Responses to several case vignettes reflecting the information provided in the CME activities were assessed for 2785 physicians who participated in the CME programs and 2836 nonparticipants.
There was a 45% increased likelihood that participants made clinical decisions in various vignettes based on clinical evidence, Casebeer and colleagues report in BioMed Central (BMC) Medicine, issued online December 4.
"This likelihood was higher in interactive case-based activities, 51%, than for text-based clinical updates, 40%," the team found. Effectiveness was higher among primary care physicians than specialists, the authors add.
"Internet CME activities show promise in offering a searchable, credible, available on-demand, high-impact source of CME for physicians," Casebeer and colleagues conclude.
BMC Medicine 2008;6. Abstract: http://www.biomedcentral.com/1741-7015/6/37/abstract
16. Thrombolytic Therapy: Not for Uncomplicated PE
Patients without hemodynamic compromise had higher mortality rates when they were given thrombolytic therapy.
Ibrahim SA, et al. Arch Intern Med. 2008;168:2183-2190. Abstract: http://archinte.ama-assn.org/cgi/content/abstract/168/20/2183
Editorial: Systemic thrombolysis effectively and rapidly dissolves clots in the pulmonary vasculature as well as the deep veins, but unlike thrombi in coronary or cerebral arteries, a PE usually does not result in permanent tissue necrosis. Provided that the patient survives the immediate hemodynamic effects of the initial event, therapy with antithrombotics alone (heparin products followed by warfarin) will usually keep further clotting at bay, allowing the body's natural fibrinolytic system to slowly dissolve any existing thromboses. This favorable response to standard anticoagulation in the majority of patients with PE, coupled with the known hemorrhagic risks of systemic thrombolysis, limits the target population for thrombolysis to those patients at high risk for hemodynamic collapse…
Brotman DJ, et al. Arch Intern Med. 2008;168:2191-2192.
17. Ultrasound in the ED Diagnosis of CHF
Identification of congestive heart failure via respiratory variation of inferior vena cava diameter
Blehar DJ, et al. Amer J Emerg Med. 2009;27:71-75.
Rapid diagnosis of volume overload in patients with suspected congestive heart failure (CHF) is necessary for the timely administration of therapeutic agents. We sought to use the measurement of respiratory variation of inferior vena cava (IVC) diameter as a diagnostic tool for identification of CHF in patients presenting with acute dyspnea.
The IVC was measured sonographically during a complete respiratory cycle of 46 patients meeting study criteria. Percentage of respiratory variation of IVC diameter was compared to the diagnosis of CHF or alternative diagnosis.
Respiratory variation of IVC was smaller in patients with CHF (9.6%) than without CHF (46%) and showed good diagnostic accuracy with area under the receiver operating characteristic curve of 0.96. Receiver operating characteristic curve analysis showed optimum cutoff of 15% variation or less of IVC diameter with 92% sensitivity and 84% specificity for the diagnosis of CHF.
Inferior vena cava ultrasound is a rapid, reliable means for identification of CHF in the acutely dyspneic patient.
18. A worrying proportion of the British medical students can’t tell their left from their right
Gormley GJ, et al. BMJ 2008;337:a2826
Right-left discrimination among medical students: questionnaire and psychometric study
Objective: To determine medical students’ self awareness and ability to discriminate right from left; to identify characteristics associated with this ability; and to identify any techniques used to aid discrimination.
Design: Questionnaire and psychometric study.
Setting: Undergraduate medical school, Northern Ireland.
Participants: 290 first year undergraduate students.
Main outcome measure: Medical students’ ability to discriminate right from left using the Bergen right-left discrimination test.
Results: Test scores ranged from 31 to 143 on a scale of 0-144 (mean 112 (standard deviation 22.2)). Male students significantly outperformed female students (117.18 (26.96) v 110.80 (28.94)). Students who wanted to be surgeons performed significantly better than those who wanted to be general practitioners or medical doctors (119.87 (25.15) v 110.55 (27.36) v 112.50 (26.88)). The interaction effect for sex and career wishes was not significant (P=0.370). Students who used learnt techniques to help them discriminate scored significantly less than those who did not (P less than 0.001). Students had greater difficulty in discriminating right from left when looking at the forward view rather than the back view (P less than 0.001).
Conclusions: Male students were better than female students at distinguishing right from left, and aspiring surgeons were better than aspiring general practitioners or medical doctors. Students had more difficulty with the forward view than the back view.
19. Use of lipid emulsion in the resuscitation of patients overdosing on lipid-soluble drugs
Sirianni AJ. Ann Emerg Med. 2008;51:412-5, 415.e1.
Animal studies show efficacy of intravenous lipid emulsion in the treatment of severe cardiotoxicity associated with local anesthetics, clomipramine, and verapamil, possibly by trapping such lipophilic drugs in an expanded plasma lipid compartment ("lipid sink"). Recent case reports describe lipid infusion for the successful treatment of refractory cardiac arrest caused by parenteral administration of local anesthetics, but clinical evidence has been lacking for lipid's antidotal efficacy on toxicity caused by ingested medications.
A 17-year-old girl developed seizure activity and cardiovascular collapse after intentional ingestion of up to 7.95 g of bupropion and 4 g of lamotrigine. Standard cardiopulmonary resuscitation for 70 minutes was unsuccessful in restoring sustained circulation. A 100-mL intravenous bolus of 20% lipid emulsion was then administered, and after 1 minute an effective sustained pulse was observed. The patient subsequently manifested significant acute lung injury but had rapid improvement in cardiovascular status and recovered, with near-normal neurologic function. Serum bupropion levels before and after lipid infusion paralleled triglyceride levels. This patient developed cardiovascular collapse because of intentional, oral overdose of bupropion and lamotrigine that was initially refractory to standard resuscitation measures. An infusion of lipid emulsion was followed rapidly by restoration of effective circulation. Toxicologic studies are consistent with the lipid sink theory of antidotal efficacy.
Followed by a letter to the editor:
Cave G, et al. Ann Emerg Med. 2008;51:449-50.
To the Editor:
We wish to congratulate Sirianni et al on their case publication “Use of Lipid Emulsion in the Resuscitation of a Patient With Prolonged Cardiovascular Collapse After Overdose of Bupropion and Lamotrigine.” This represents a major step in the evolution of lipid emulsion as antidotal therapy in lipid-soluble drug cardiotoxicity, and is the first to demonstrate effect in an enteric overdose of lipid soluble drug.
Application of lipid infusion in local anesthetic-induced cardiotoxicity follows pioneering work by Weinberg and others demonstrating efficacy in animal models, and subsequently successful case publications. Re-establishment of new plasma equibrilium favoring sequestration of lipophilic drugs into a newly created intravascular compartment is the currently proposed mechanism of action. We have additionally demonstrated efficacy for lipid infusion in animal models of clomipramine and verapamil toxicity, suggesting potential benefit in deliberate overdose from these lipid soluble agents.
Guidelines advocating lipid emulsion as therapy for local anesthetic cardiotoxocity have recently been published by The Association of Anaesthetists of Great Britain and Ireland.6 We would endeavor to contribute to the “bringing over” of lipid therapy for lipophilic drug toxidromes from the anesthetic domain to the general toxicologic domain wherein we believe the greatest benefit is likely to be manifest.
The use of lipid emulsion as antidote should, however, progress with some caution. Enthusiasm and imprudence are common bedfellows in the commendation and application of novel medical therapies. The special setting encountered by Sirianni et al, that of refractory arrest despite all conventional therapy, is one where use of lipid emulsion is rational. The only potential alteration to outcome is benefit. Indiscriminate application of this therapy at the expense of validated antidotal therapies is unwarranted at this point. We would echo the call of the anesthetic literature for the use of lipid emulsion in the setting of lipophilic drug cardiotoxicity where death is adjudged inevitable despite all available alternative therapies.
Finally, as the nature and presentation of life-threatening lipophilic drug intoxication renders systemic human study impractical, animal modelling and case publication are likely to represent the avenues by which lipid therapy may advance. It is therefore the responsibility of individual clinicians to disseminate their experience with lipid therapy, both successes and otherwise. Moreover we would implore editors to publish such case reports both positive and negative. In time a major new therapy may be available to severely intoxicated patients.
20. Screening Laboratory and Radiology Panels for Trauma Patients Have Low Utility and Are Not Cost Effective
Tasse JL, et al. J Trauma 2008;65:1114-1116.
Background: Routine laboratory and radiology panels as part of the initial evaluation of the trauma patient are prevalent practices. This is a study of utility and cost effectiveness of this practice.
Methods: During a 3-month period, trauma panels were analyzed for cost and impact on patient care in our institution.
Results: Four hundred ten consecutive patients had 3,982 studies (cost $417,839) performed of which 1,292 (cost $114,753) were abnormal and only 253 (cost $36,703) were clinically contributory.
Conclusions: Routine panels are not useful or cost effective. Negative results contribute little to management. Selective and targeted studies should be indicated by the secondary survey, and may result in substantial cost savings ($1,500,000 per year at our institution).
21. Inability to get up after falling, subsequent time on floor, and summoning help: prospective cohort study in people over 90
Fleming J, et al. BMJ 2008;337:a2227
Objectives: To describe the incidence and extent of lying on the floor for a long time after being unable to get up from a fall among people aged over 90; to explore their use of call alarm systems in these circumstances.
Design: 1 year follow-up of participants in a prospective cohort study of ageing, using fall calendars, phone calls, and visits.
Setting: Participants’ usual place of residence (own homes or care homes), mostly in Cambridge.
Participants: 90 women and 20 men aged over 90 (n=110), surviving participants of the Cambridge City over-75s Cohort, a population based sample.
Main outcome measures: Inability to get up without help, lying on floor for a long time after falling, associated factors; availability and use of call alarm systems; participants’ views on using call alarms to summon help if needed after falling.
Results: In one year’s intensive follow-up, 54% (144/265) of fall reports described the participant as being found on the floor and 82% (217/265) of falls occurred when the person was alone. Of the 60% who fell, 80% (53/66) were unable to get up after at least one fall and 30% (20/66) had lain on the floor for an hour or more. Difficulty in getting up was consistently associated with age, reported mobility, and severe cognitive impairment. Cognition was the only characteristic that predicted lying on the floor for a long time. Lying on the floor for a long time was strongly associated with serious injuries, admission to hospital, and subsequent moves into long term care. Call alarms were widely available but were not used in most cases of falls that led to lying on the floor for a long time. Comments from older people and carers showed the complexity of issues around the use of call alarms, including perceptions of irrelevance, concerns about independence, and practical difficulties.
Conclusions: Lying on the floor for a long time after falling is more common among the "oldest old" than previously thought and is associated with serious consequences. Factors indicating higher risk and comments from participants suggest practical implications. People need training in strategies to get up from the floor. Work is needed on access and activation issues for design of call alarms and information for their effective use. Care providers need better understanding of the perceptions of older people to provide acceptable support services.